By Erik Garcia
//
November 17, 2026
Every agency owner will exit their business one day. Financial readiness can be measured, but there’s no spreadsheet that tells you when you’re ready to let go of something you spent decades building.
In this episode of The Human Side of Selling Your Agency, a special series from Stuff About Money, host Erik Garcia, CFP®, BFA is joined by guest co-hosts Matt Naimoli and Dr. Matt Morris, LMFT to explore why the decision to sell is so hard. They look at why the goalposts keep moving and how owners can untangle the emotions behind a sale. Then guest Brent Thurman takes us to the 11th hour of his own sale. After nine months of work, the final offer was in his hands, the butterflies hit, and he had to answer one question: “Am I really ready to do this?”
Episode Highlights:
- Erik shares an International Exit Planning Association finding that 82% of business owners had low mental readiness to sell. (06:51)
- Matt Naimoli shares the three things prepared sellers are clear on: why they are selling, what enough looks like, and their day-to-day after the sale. (25:32)
- Dr. Matt Morris explains why suddenly receiving a wealth windfall can feel overwhelming and disorienting. (44:21)
- Brent shares how he started Keystone Insurance in 2003 in the Orem and Provo area, focusing mostly on personal lines. (51:39)
- Brent explains how a conversation with his fractional CFO, Carrie Wallace, led him to finally explore a sale. (54:09)
- Brent explains why an agency needs a critical mass of revenue and profit before a strong multiple makes a sale worthwhile. (55:35)
- Brent shares how his wife, son, and long-time employees made the decision on an emotional journey. (56:26)
- Hiring a firm to take the agency to market can take pressure off the owner throughout the process. (58:19)
- Brent shares how Mike, who was guiding him through the sale, told him not to sign unless it felt right. (01:00:18)
- Brent explains why the sale was primarily a financial decision, since his day-to-day life would stay the same. (01:03:40)
- Brent shares why having an experienced advisor in his corner felt validating throughout the process. (01:08:21)
- Owners thinking about selling are encouraged to look at their numbers today, even if a sale is years away. (01:10:50)
Key Quotes:
- “I want people to think better about the idea of selling because, here’s the reality, every business owner’s going to exit one way or another. Might as well be on your terms, right?” – Erik Garcia, CFP®, BFA
- “You identify the emotion, you talk through it, and then you figure out, is there an action that helps me avoid a problem or better process this, right? Or there’s no action, but I already talked about it, so I feel better about it.” – Matt Naimoli
- “Both the financial and the emotional really need to be attended to or taken care of and we all have the ability to deal with complex emotions.” – Dr. Matt Morris, LMFT
Resources Mentioned:
Your First Step to Financial Security
Schedule your Strategy Session
Curious about working with Plan Wisely? Schedule your no-obligation 30-minute strategy session with us to explore how we can help you achieve your goals.
Schedule time with Erik
Schedule time with Xavier
